Vital Football

Latest Swansea City News

Talking Points: Monk's Use of Substitutions vs Norwich

Talking Points: Monk's Use of Substitutions vs Norwich
Swansea City manager Garry Monk's substitution decisions came into question on Saturday as his side lost their 5th game in 8, as Norwich City scored from a corner to take all three points at Carrow Road.

After a disappointing 3-0 defeat against Arsenal last weekend, the next two games against promoted sides Norwich and Bournemouth were seen as an opportunity to get some much needed points on the board to ease our slide down the Premier League table.

However, things didn't go to plan on Saturday as Swansea City produced yet another disappointing and lacklustre performance that lacked all of the qualities that he wanted to bring to the club after they had been 'eroded' by his predecesor Michael Laudrup.

The team seemed happy enough to try and keep the ball for as long as possible, and play out a boring 0-0 draw, lacking ambition and the will to try and win all three points.

Monk may have just blamed a 'lapse of concentration' for conceding directly from a corner - AGAIN - but the disappointing and frustrating fact is that his side never ever looking like scoring. Ruddy - in the Norwich goal rarely touched the ball with his hands and didn't have a single save to make - in fact the only time he did touch the ball with his hands was when he was setting the ball for a goal kick.

8 minutes after his side went a goal down with 20 minutes remaining, Garry Monk made the strange decision to take off an attacking midfielder - Gylfi Sigurdsson - who scored a stunning free kick that helped us complete a come back win at Aston Villa a fortnight ago, and replace him with holding midfielder Leon Britton.

Sigurdsson, who has proven that he can change a game for us recently from a dead ball situation, leaves the pitch with 12 minutes of the game to go, while struggling striker Bafetimbi Gomis is left to play the full 90 minutes, while second choice striker Eder has to wait yet again to make a cameo with a handful of minutes of the game remaining.

Britton did play well when he came on, helped us to keep possession as we all know he does so well, and while it did allow one of Ki and Shelvey to push further forward, it didn't improve our already-slim chances of netting an equaliser late on in the game.

Wayne Routledge's arrival on the hour mark, replacing a poor Montero was the only worthy replacement of the game for the Swans. Routledge did create our one chance of the game - as Gylfi Sigurdsson - the player later taken off - somehow managed to loop a shot onto the bar from short range.

The only explanation is if Sigurdsson was suffering with an injury of some sort, but this didn't look to be the case. And with Gomis being no threat whatsoever again, why not bring on Eder a lot sooner?

I, and many many other fans cannot understand why Eder is only getting a maximum of 5 minutes when coming on as a substitute. I actually feel quite sorry for the Portuguese international striker. What can we expect him to do for 5 minutes per game?! And fans are calling for him to replace Gomis up front, but how can we expect him to suddenly start games when he's only playing for a few minutes every week!?

Those are our thoughts, what do you think? Do you agree? Post your comments below...

Date:Monday November 9 2015
Time: 3:09PM

Best of International Football News


Yes his subs are strange to say the least. Shouldn't substitutes be used to change the pattern of a game, or to alter tactics? He's not doing either at the moment.
Phil W
11/11/2015 10:18:00
He was doing the same last season, especially at the start of the season. He was getting a lot of criticism for ineffective subs and just making like for like changes. They're the same and predictable every game, it's getting boring and annoying now. Changes are needed far earlier in games, like taking Gomis off at half time!
11/11/2015 13:29:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Swansea City Articles

Rate The Players: Brighton & Hove Albion 4-1 Swansea City

Rate the players' performances in Swansea City's 4-1 away defeat against Brighton & Hove Albion.

Thoughts as Carvalhal Gamble Doesn't Pay Off at Brighton

Carlos Carvalhal's attacking gamble at Brighton & HA backfired as his side lost 4-1 to put them back into the bottom three

Stats: Brighton & HA v Swansea City

All the stats from Brighton & HA (4) vs (1) Swansea City, Amex Stadium, 24th February 2018 Att: 30,523

Team Line-Ups: Brighton & HA vs Swansea City

Confirmed team line-ups as Swansea City face Brighton & HA

Swansea City Archived Articles

Vital Swansea City articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Vote for your man of the match vs Brighton
Suggested By:
van der Hoorn0%
Jordan Ayew25%
Andre Ayew0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Swansea City Results (view all)

Swansea City Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

1.Phil W12
2.Dennis Downing5
5.shearers boots1
The Vital Football Members League