Vital Football

Latest Swansea City News

Brighton & HA 4-1 - Glass Half Full / Half Empty

Brighton & HA 4-1 - Glass Half Full / Half Empty

There are often two ways of looking at a Swansea City result, particularly a defeat, you can focus on the positives (if there are any) or mainly the negatives.

There haven't been many defeats this season where you could focus on only the positives, you'd have to be clutching for the majority of them to find something positive, but Saturday's heavy 4-1 defeat at Brighton and Hove Albion - one of our closest relegation rivals, has been discussed and analyzed differently by Swansea City fans.

It was a big and disappointing defeat, as we were knocked back down to earth after an excellent run under new boss Carlos Carvalhal.

The main focus after the game was the manager's choice of substitutions, as early as the 36th minute when he hooked off an ineffective Nathan Dyer for Andre Ayew - to make his second appearance since his deadline day move from West Ham United.

The game pretty much turned on its head midway through the second half, when we conceded two goals in four minutes as Carvalhal went for broke, making his third substitution after just 66 minutes, and three minutes later the game looked out of our reach at 2-0.

Some fans were happy to see a manager being bold and positive, while others - including me - were more disappointed to see us make a third change when we were already looking very vulnerable to the counter-attack, as Brighton took full advantage and exploited the hole in the defence that was left behind when van der Hoorn was taken off at halftime for Luciano Narsingh.

So in terms of glass half full/half empty, the penalty was a soft one after just 18 minutes. Soft because van der Hoorn was clumsy and it was easily an avoidable spot kick.

Had we kept things goalless at the break, then maybe Carvalhal wouldn't have felt the need for such reckless and early changes. We'd probably have defended better, rather than showing signs of the Bob Bradley days when their fourth went in.

The early Dyer-Ayew swap was a valid one, van der Hoorn coming off to switch to a back four was bold at the break, but the third sub of Abraham was baffling, to say the least, considering how vulnerable we looked at the time.

Had we avoided the penalty, we might not have changed shape as early as we did, keeping the score within reach and going for it in the final 20-25 minutes as we have done so well in recent wins.

Another disappointment was seeing us only creating a single shot on target in the whole game, despite having 6 attackers on the pitch for the final quarter of the game. Ki and Clucas were in the middle, with the two Ayew brothers, Narsingh and Abraham in front of them, and we didn't really look like getting back in the game. Abraham scored a consolation late on before Brighton added a fourth to really sink us.

The endeavour on display was also lacking and this has to act as a wake-up call as we have some crucial games coming up against fellow strugglers. Increased energy and intensity levels have played a big part in the recent revival under Carvalhal, but it was severely lacking at the Amex this weekend.

How did you see the game? Can/will we stay up despite the 4-1 defeat and setback? Let us know what you thought in the comments below...

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Sunday February 25 2018
Time: 8:30PM

Login to post a comment

Recent Swansea City Articles

Carvalhal Not Disappointed Despite Poor Cup Exit

Carlos Carvalhal said he wasn't disappointed despite our poor performance and exit from the FA Cup at home against Spurs

Stats: Swansea City v Tottenham Hotspur

All the stats from Swansea City (0) vs (3) Tottenham Hotspur, Liberty Stadium, 17th March 2018 Att:

FA Cup Team Line-Ups: Swansea City vs Tottenham Hotspur

Confirmed team Line-Ups as Swansea City host Spurs in the Fa Cup quarter-final

Clucas Explains Differences Between Carvalhal & Clement

Sam Clucas has explained the differences between current boss Carlos Carvalhal and his predecessor Paul Clement

Swansea City Archived Articles

Vital Swansea City articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Vote for your man of the match vs Huddersfield Town
Suggested By:
van der Hoorn19%
Andre Ayew4%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Swansea City Results (view all)

Swansea City Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Phil W8
2.keith margam2
4.Dennis Downing1
Write for Vital Football