Vital Football

Latest Swansea City News

Player Ratings: Swansea City 0-4 Manchester United

Player Ratings: Swansea City 0-4 Manchester United

Player ratings and comments from Saturday's game as Swansea City lost 4-0 at home against Manchester United.

Lucasz Fabianski - 6

Had little to do for first 70-80 minutes and made a good save to try and stop the first goal but couldn't recover in time to clear the ball from danger. Distribution seems to have improved, no kicks going out of touch and couldn't have done better with the goals.

Kyle Naughton - 6.5

A player that often receives criticism but had a solid game defensively, but he was unsupported when attacking down the right in the 3-5-2 system.

Federico Fernandez - 7

An excellent performance for the vast majority of the game but it was baffling what he was doing for the first goal. Rather than attempting to hook the ball clear, he just stands there with his arms out expecting Fabianski to claim the loose ball. For the second, he, along with Mawson are caught ball watching, leaving Lukaku free inside the box. Those two instances let him down, but for the rest of the game he was excellent, and was always effective at closing down and eliminating the threat.

Kyle Bartley - 7.5

A contender for man of the match for his marking job on Lukaku - helping to keep him uninvolved. Proved to be a useful player to have when adopting three at the back.

Alfie Mawson - 6

The weakest of the centre backs. For the first time under Paul Clement, he looked a bit on edge, and struggled up against United. Passing wasn't quite as good as we're used to from him and rarely got tight on his markers in the defensive third.

Martin Olsson - 6.5

Plenty of effort from Olsson down the left, solid defensively and unlike Naughton, has the benefit of having Tom Carroll to link-up with alongside him and will be a good asset when playing a 3-5-2, but some of his final balls lacked accuracy.

Roque Mesa - 6

A decent full debut from Mesa but not specular. Didn't quite get on the ball as much as he probably would have wanted but that was partly down to our style of play now and playing through the full backs. You could see what Clement was talking about when he needs to get used to the increased tempo of the Premier League as he did make one bad missplaced bad pass that gave United a chance to run towards goal. He'll only improve and there was plenty there to suggest that he can fill in for Leon Britton.

Leroy Fer - 5.5

Fer can pick out a good long-range pass that we need, particularly getting the ball away from a crowded area and into space to help us move forward, but when we're out of possession - particularly when Clement made the changes, his attitude falls away. He tried doing a fancy trick before getting robbed before one of the goals, and for the rest he jogged back slowly as Pogba ran through to lift the ball over Fabianski. You have to feel that his place is one of the main ones up for grabs when we sign a few players.

Tom Carroll - 7

Very busy on the ball and was excellent in possession for most of the game, very disciplined positionally but he struggled after the changes - like Fer. Made a bad pass that was intercepted for one of United's goals, but other than that, he's a key player for us. Also did a good job with his corners, but we need Llorente in there to make better use of them, sent in a good cross for Abraham who headed over.

Jordan Ayew - 5

Ayew, like Fer is another player I feel that needs to improve or risk getting dropped when new players come in. He loves a dribble, but he kept running into a crowd of United players and losing position. We needed better hold up play front 2 - such was the gap between them and the midfield, but Ayew always wanted to go on his solo runs.

Tammy Abraham - 5.5

A tough game for Abraham, lacked support and desperately needs a number 10 behind him to link with or a better hold up player like Llorente to work off. The Spaniard might have done better with his headed chance in the second half, but other than that he had no service.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Monday August 21 2017
Time: 10:26PM


How on god's green earth does Mawson, Carroll, Fer and Naughton score more than Ayew?
Dennis Downing
21/08/2017 22:46:00
Mainly because it's my opinion Dennis. This is the problem with player ratings, everyone sees things differently and some things may go unnoticed, while others just stand out more. A lot of people I've spoken to seem to agree on Ayew though that he was poor. Please share your ratings too.
Vital Swansea City
21/08/2017 23:07:00
Everyone has different opinions but I have to agree that Ayew was very poor. He's good with the ball and going forwards but hardly ever tracks back and just cannot hold the ball up. Fer is a luxury we just cannot afford. He is not a central midfielder and would much prefer to attack at all times. He loses the ball constantly and once Mesa went off he went missing. I just couldn't understand why Clement changed from a back 3 to a 4. He says it was to make us more attack minded but it had the opposite effect as our fullbacks sat back and invited Utd's wide men to go forward. A bad decision I reckon.
Phil W
22/08/2017 10:06:00
My man of the match was Bartley. That was the best he has played for us and Mawson should have come off not him. Mawson was awful throughout, was at fault for the first goal as he was marking no-one and was ball watching for the second. Needs a rest I think as he is a young player. Yes we were good down the left with Olsen and Carroll but we had no right sided midfield player and this is something that Clement needs to address. Overall it showed how much we missed Llorente's hold up play, we need time to get forward and too often the ball was lost between Ayew and Abrahams.
Phil W
22/08/2017 10:26:00
Ayew was our worst player on the day - offered nothing, Mawson second worst and then Fer for me. Bartley and Fernandez best.
22/08/2017 19:18:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of International Football News

Recent Swansea City Articles

Stats: Brighton & HA v Swansea City

All the stats from Brighton & HA (4) vs (1) Swansea City, Amex Stadium, 24th February 2018 Att: 30,523

Team Line-Ups: Brighton & HA vs Swansea City

Confirmed team line-ups as Swansea City face Brighton & HA

One Transfer Deadline Was Never Enough Was It

You've got to love the football authorities, if transfer deadline days weren't ridiculous enough already - they've now begun to breed.

Swansea City Injury List Hit For Six

Our weekly update looking at the injury table for Swansea City FC and also comparing with all our competitors in the Premier League.

Swansea City Archived Articles

Vital Swansea City articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Vote for your man of the match vs Sheffield Wednesday
Suggested By:
van der Hoorn59%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Swansea City Results (view all)

Swansea City Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Phil W12
2.Dennis Downing5
5.shearers boots1
The Vital Football Members League